Previous Posts & Commentary
Previous Posts
What is this "AI" thou speak of? Dost thou utilize it? (May 15, 2026)
There are several “hot topics” in the Renfaire realm at the moment – we’re going to touch on one this week, and a few others (one per week or so) over the next several weeks. Because mine writing style is “be thorough and combat the naysayers from the start,” you’ll get the TL;DR up front, especially for folks on mobile devices.
AI: we don’t allow our vendors to use AI to create products they vend (no 3-D printing, either, but that’s a different topic) and that is written into the application they fill out. Oakenmist doesn’t use it to create imagery for marketing or online media purposes. We have experimented with it (and concluded it’s less than useful) in the past, and we use tools that can utilize AI for imagery – but we specify non-AI when we use them. We do use AI for documentation and organizational functions, because it’s less resource-intensive than hours of online searching with the same result.
**************
This week’s topic is “Generative AI” – so-called “artificial intelligence.” Defined loosely, AI is computing performed at a facility that consumes mass amounts of resources (space, power, water). Generally, the objection to it’s use is twofold: first, artisans should not use AI to create new image-based art. AI is incapable of creating original artwork – it has been charged with appropriating current photography and imagery, then editing such to create something “new.” That appropriation is typically artwork utilized without the original creator’s permission, and without compensation or credit. While there are avenues where that’s acceptable (say, parody), AI is not typically used in this fashion, and court rulings have thus made clear that AI artwork cannot be owned or copyrighted. In short – it appears that AI has a ways to go before it can honestly create artwork “from scratch.”
Oakenmist does not allow such use for our vendors, and that’s specified in the application – vendors agree to that as a condition of application. If they’ve used it and said they haven’t – we shall have a prompt medieval-style removal from the Faire. Even when AI matures to the point where it can create actual new material, we’ll probably prohibit it.
The second objection is when groups use AI as a method for creating advertising or marketing imagery, especially items that are publicized electronically. The backlash has been strong enough that not only is this shunned in the Renfaire community, but most major media creation providers present the option to specifically exclude the use of AI for all of their users (full disclosure: we utilize Canva, no AI.) In truth, we at Oakenmist experimented with it 2 years ago – but we weren’t thrilled with the outcome, and after discussion with several artists, we chose to explicitly go down a non-AI imagery path, especially given that the Renaissance community tends to support individual artisans and makers.
There are plenty of visuals that have existed for a decade or more that some in the RenFaire (and other) community have tried to call out as AI-generated; that’s clearly not the case as some visuals predate AI per se. So we as a Faire and the community as a whole need to be cautious in throwing that “AI” charge around – we have additional checks to ensure this inside of the Oakenmist team. Now, that being said, do we use AI in other roles? We have used it to create outlines for first generation marketing plans and initial documentation, for example – where we could generate the same thing via 50 online searches and a bunch of typing – but the “load” on data center systems would probably be greater than if we just asked AI to do it directly. Given the tradeoffs, we consider the use of AI in those types of situations reasonable. We’re talking about a technology that has the potential for significant good in the world – the Mayo Clinic released a study 2 weeks ago showing that AI can detect certain cancers up to 3 years earlier than a traditional diagnosis. Society shouldn’t discard the technology as a whole – there are differences in their use. Oakenmist believes that there is appropriate use of AI – but “creative imagery” isn’t one of those uses.
d'Artagnan is found! (April 9, 2026)
Why Westminster? (March 27, 2026)
They grow apples in England? (August 3, 2025)
Soft drinks invented during the Renaissance (July 21, 2025)
Air conditioning and the Renaissance (July 10, 2025)
How do you address others at a RenFaire? (August 9, 2024)
Who are all of these non-Renaissance garbed people? Why are they here? (July 18, 2024)
RenFaire performers then and now (July 5, 2024)
How did this Renaissance Faire thing start, anyway? And who picked the date for this thing? (June 28, 2024)
A hamlet? A town? A village? Who cares, and what's the difference? (June 17, 2024)
Our take on mass produced items from our vendors (July 18, 2023)
So what should you find at a Renaissance Faire? (June 28, 2023)
We thank you for your consideration and cooperation and look forward to seeing you at the Faire!